Sora's latest long music video generation attempt failed
The music video for Washed Out's "The Hardest Part," created with OpenAI's Sora, has received very mixed reviews, with its surreal quality admired by some, but criticized by others for its visual inconsistencies and "uncanny valley" feel. User @gamegame6089 said "The visual is like urban legend creepy pasta. At a glance it looks normal, at a second and third glance its looks like nightmare." while another user @outerspic complained: "The future is digital diarrhea.".
The applauded "Air Head" video took a lot of human labor
Recent insights reveal that while OpenAI's Sora can generate realistic videos from text, manual post-production work is still essential to refine these outputs, as evidenced by the extensive editing needed for the viral "Air Head" video.
Key Takeaways
- Creative Freedom: Director Paul Trillo leveraged Sora to generate dozens of unique clips, enabling ambitious creative concepts previously constrained by budget and logistics.
- Technical Limitations: Despite its innovative approach, Sora struggles with maintaining visual continuity, affecting the consistency of characters and environments from scene to scene.
- Mixed Reactions: While some viewers appreciate the video's dreamlike aesthetic, others are put off by its unnatural character movements and rapid transitions.
- Future Potential: The video illustrates both the capabilities and current shortcomings of AI in video production, suggesting a significant evolution is still required to match human precision.
- Post-Production Needs: Despite Sora's capabilities, inconsistencies like visual artifacts still necessitate some manual editing.
- Feedback and Testing: Sora is undergoing testing with professionals in visual arts and film, aiming to minimize these editing needs through iterative improvements.
- Real-World Application: The "Air Head" video required significant manual editing, including color correction and element removal, highlighting current limitations in fully automated video production.
Analysis
The creation of "The Hardest Part" music video showcases the transformative potential of AI in filmmaking, particularly for experimental and avant-garde projects. However, the noticeable discrepancies and the need for substantial post-production adjustments highlight Sora's limitations. As AI technology progresses, it could redefine creative processes in the film industry, but it must first overcome these fundamental challenges.
The need for manual post-production work on videos generated by Sora, despite its advanced capabilities, underscores the challenges in achieving truly autonomous video creation. While Sora represents a significant step forward, the detailed editing work done on projects like "Air Head" illustrates that human intervention is still crucial for achieving professional quality. This gap indicates a potential focus area for further development and refinement in AI-driven video production technologies.
Did You Know?
Despite the advanced AI technology used in the production of the "The Hardest Part" video, significant manual editing was still necessary to achieve the final product. This included detailed tasks such as rotoscoping, color correction, and removing unwanted elements—underscoring the current necessity for human oversight in AI-generated content.
The "Air Head" video, which required extensive post-production work, had a staggering 300:1 ratio of generated content to edited content, showcasing the intensive effort needed to polish AI-generated visuals to meet professional standards.